It's not how fast poles change from N to S, but rather how fast the lines of magnetic flux pass through the conductor (ie the wires) that determines voltage output.
Stepper motor Alternator
- Thread starter Rdean33422
- Start date
Help Support Home Model Engine Machinist Forum:
It's not how fast poles change from N to S, but rather how fast the lines of magnetic flux pass through the conductor (ie the wires) that determines voltage output.
At least the aircraft industry got it right: 400 Hz is the standard for all airplanes regardless what country makes them.
Green Twin is right when he noted that you'll start running into problems as you get into higher frequencies. The laminated iron cores used in most motors, including steppers, when used as alternators, will become less efficient as the frequency increases. This is mostly due to eddy currents within the iron laminations. Higher frequency typically requires the use of powdered iron core or ferrite materials.
AC Power is a lot more complex than the simple description I gave, but many mechanical folk shy away from "AC" as being "too complex" for their needs or understanding. - in my long experience. The demonstrated experience of voltage and frequency varying linearly with speed is one simple aspect that I tried to explain. But the "Whole power" is subject to "Volts x Amps" - so you have to at least add a resistive load and measure Current as well as voltage to tell the "Whole story" of what happens, and whether it is worth pursuing as a power generator. Only when you add a load will the generator apply a proper load to the motor.
K2
K2
In my experiments the load was a 7 watt led light bulb so how does that compare to work done? Is this power output capable of charging a cell phone battery using a wall wart?
How would the high frequency effect the wall wart output?
Ray
How would the high frequency effect the wall wart output?
Ray
Just from observation, it appears in your video that the light was glowing at a normal brightness, so if it was, your stepper alternator is making at least 7 watts of power; it could be capable of outputting more watts, but you haven't given us enough data to know.
IF 7 watts is the max output from your stepper, it would take a very long time to charge a cell phone, and the plug-in phone charger likely will not work very well at the high frequency your stepper is providing.
If you have some old incandescent light bulbs, the type with filaments inside that glow, not LED or Fluorescent, try using those instead of your 7 watt LED bulb; something around 25 watt to 100 watt. Before you plug the light into your stepper-alternator, use your meter to measure the bulb's resistance in Ohms,...should be a few hundred Ohms.
Run the test as you did with the LED light and measure the voltage. The current (in Amps) you're stepper is making will be: Amps = Volts/Ohms. And the power you're making will be Watts = Amps x Volts.
Steppers are a fun way to make a little power when used as an alternator,....but if you want to make real usable power, replace the stepper with a PM (Permanent Magnet) motor. Most any motor from a cordless power tool will work nicely, or you can buy one from eBay.
Last edited:
Just to mention that filament lamps have low resistance when cold. They have a resistance ration of between 13 -15:1 between cold and hot. All filament lamps have a resistance slope including car lamps. It's the inrush current that causes a weak cold filament to fail.
From the number of poles, a stepper motor should be a useful demonstration generator for an odd LED or three, when run by a slow running steam or hit and miss IC engine. PM Hand tool (drill) motors usually run at 10s. of thousands rpm to develop their power: I.E. Relatively small voltages from the DC battery but relatively high current: a 240W motor at 24V is drawing 10A on load. If run as a generator at less than 1000rpm you may only get 1 or 2 volts, - and similarly only tens of milliamps as a result. - The net power output being only a couple of watts. Gearing to get the generator speed you want can sap all the engine's power.
Conversely, a stepper motor, with 10 or more times the poles of a "power" motor, will generate the voltages at low revs but with very small current (amps) - as demonstrated by Ray - thus generating a few watts but at (possibly?) more useable voltages? I suspect these devices vary so much for different applications, makes, and sizes there is no simple rule to getting a stepper motor to match your application except by trial and tribulation!
I would be keen to use a diode bridge to convert the stepper motor output to DC to eliminate the high frequency from ruining any downstream (semi-conductor) devices, other than resistance wire bulbs.
Personally, I look to bicycle generators for my small steam engines, as they are designed to generate the single figure voltages and currents for torch bulbs at speeds suitable for the low speeds and low power of my engines, with small enough belt drives to look OK. They can be hidden inside "generator shaped" housings as well!
For some I use bridge diodes to rectify the variable frequency AC, then a Buck controller to get the controlled DC output for the LEDs that I have. This configuration may suit Ray - with parts such as these but that you select to match your input voltage and output voltages?
e,g.
W04M 400V Bridge Rectifier Diode 1.5A
6-24V Input to 5V 2A Output USB Charger Module DC-DC Buck Step-Down Converter
Thanks to all contributors here as I have learned a lot about stepper motors, from a zero baseline of knowledge!
K2
Conversely, a stepper motor, with 10 or more times the poles of a "power" motor, will generate the voltages at low revs but with very small current (amps) - as demonstrated by Ray - thus generating a few watts but at (possibly?) more useable voltages? I suspect these devices vary so much for different applications, makes, and sizes there is no simple rule to getting a stepper motor to match your application except by trial and tribulation!
I would be keen to use a diode bridge to convert the stepper motor output to DC to eliminate the high frequency from ruining any downstream (semi-conductor) devices, other than resistance wire bulbs.
Personally, I look to bicycle generators for my small steam engines, as they are designed to generate the single figure voltages and currents for torch bulbs at speeds suitable for the low speeds and low power of my engines, with small enough belt drives to look OK. They can be hidden inside "generator shaped" housings as well!
For some I use bridge diodes to rectify the variable frequency AC, then a Buck controller to get the controlled DC output for the LEDs that I have. This configuration may suit Ray - with parts such as these but that you select to match your input voltage and output voltages?
e,g.
W04M 400V Bridge Rectifier Diode 1.5A
6-24V Input to 5V 2A Output USB Charger Module DC-DC Buck Step-Down Converter
Thanks to all contributors here as I have learned a lot about stepper motors, from a zero baseline of knowledge!
K2
Yep, ideally Rdean should use a wire wound resistor rated at something above 25 watts,...100 watts would be better. I have those laying around my shop, but not many people do; it's far more likely Rdean has some old light bulbs laying around the house. As long as the bulb's filament doesn't start to glow during his testing, the bulb's resistance shouldn't change too much; I'll be quite surprised if his stepper alternator manages to cause a 25 Watt bulb to glow.
Thank you all for the insight and knowledge. I will give the regular light bulb a try.
Ray
Ray
Here's a picture of a quick test I ran a few minutes ago: I'm spinning a small PM motor I took out of an old cordless drill; it's fairly small, about the same size as the chuck on my drill. I measured the rpm at 1,012 before I took this pic. The brown cylinder shaped object in the pic is a 15 Ohm resistor which the output of the motor is connected to via the red and white wires. The meter is showing 3.66 Volts DC. Using Ohms Law, Amps= V/R = 3.66 V/15 Ohms = 0.244 Amps or 244 milliamps. And since amps times volts = watts, this tiny motor running at just 1000 rpm is producing 0.89 watts, or very close to 1 watt. At 2000 rpm I would expect about 7 VDC at close to 1/2 amp, which should be fine for charging a cell phone with no need for wall chargers. At 4000 rpm I would expect to see a bit over 14 VDC which you could plug a car phone charger into
. Again, this is a tiny motor; measuring 1.5" diameter and 2" long.
Last edited:
I was able to get short a quick test done.
I measured the resistance of the light bulb cold and it was 45 ohms.
The motor was running at 2000 rpms with the load connected.
The voltage was 70.
Amps = Volts/Resistance
1.55 = 70/45
Watts = Amps * Volts
108.5 = 1.55 * 70
Did I figure this right?
The bulb was less than half bright and if I could have upped the rpms higher it would have been brighter.
You see I did not have the engine secured to the bench so I was chasing it around while I was trying to get the readings. I will be better prepared next time.
Ray
I measured the resistance of the light bulb cold and it was 45 ohms.
The motor was running at 2000 rpms with the load connected.
The voltage was 70.
Amps = Volts/Resistance
1.55 = 70/45
Watts = Amps * Volts
108.5 = 1.55 * 70
Did I figure this right?
The bulb was less than half bright and if I could have upped the rpms higher it would have been brighter.
You see I did not have the engine secured to the bench so I was chasing it around while I was trying to get the readings. I will be better prepared next time.
Ray
Good Job!! Your math is flawless, proving your stepper is producing far more power than I had expected, and much more than you will need to charge a cell phone. As a bonus, since the bulb had begun to glow, you know that the resistance had dropped below 45 ohms, meaning your steam powered stepper is actually making more than 108.5 watts. If you want to get a better measurement of how much power your stepper is producing, try using a larger bulb,...one that doesn't glow at all or even get warm when its powered with your stepper. You could also try a two slice toaster; they're typically rated at 800 to 1200 watts, which shouldn't even get warm using your stepper alternator.
EDIT NOTE: My above statement that resistance drops as filament temperature increases is incorrect. Increasing Temperature of wire resistors will cause the resistance to also increase. Meaning your stepper is most likely making less than 108.5 watts.
Last edited:
It is a gas powered twin cylinder engine but it just doesn't seem right.
I need to do some more tests maybe on a different stepper motor.
Ray
I need to do some more tests maybe on a different stepper motor.
Ray
If you happen to have one, or don't mind buying one, the motors used on drones, called "outrunners" make excellent alternators. They come in lots of different sizes, power levels, and voltage ranges, and their output is 3-phase AC. So, another option for you to consider and/or play with
Last edited:
Toymaker
You have this wrong. (As a bonus, since the bulb had begun to glow, you know that the resistance had dropped below 45 ohms, meaning your steam powered stepper is actually making more than 108.5 watts.)
As the bulb heats up the resistance go up.
You have this wrong. (As a bonus, since the bulb had begun to glow, you know that the resistance had dropped below 45 ohms, meaning your steam powered stepper is actually making more than 108.5 watts.)
As the bulb heats up the resistance go up.
Good catch,... I was wrong. I must have been thinking of power transistors ;-)
Toymaker, whatever goes wrong in your head is exactly the same as mine... - possibly a "mathematical dyslexion" - or whatever, that I couldn't spell without Google!
I am very grateful to all those who correct my maships!
K2
I am very grateful to all those who correct my maships!
K2
Ray. What you are demonstrating is a generator that will probably provide 210V at 6000rpm - if the insulation is good enough! But what does the rating plate say on the stepper motor? (Maybe as you are in the USA you can work on 110V at 3000rpm instead, to suit your light bulb?)
I also suspect that when you get 210V you'll power a 220~240V filament bulb nicely... and have a clue to the wattage you can generate. Don't be surprised if your gas engine does produce a couple of hundred watts at those sorts of speeds.
If you know you jet sizes, and gas pressure at wide open throttle, I can deduce an approximate "gas power" you are introducing to the engine. All the kW of gas introduced comes out as heat (bearings, water jacket, exhaust, etc.) and electrical power. If 10% efficient I can believe you are inputting 2kW of "gas" to get 200w of electrical power...
But let's have some numbers and play with the Engineering!
Thanks,
K2
I also suspect that when you get 210V you'll power a 220~240V filament bulb nicely... and have a clue to the wattage you can generate. Don't be surprised if your gas engine does produce a couple of hundred watts at those sorts of speeds.
If you know you jet sizes, and gas pressure at wide open throttle, I can deduce an approximate "gas power" you are introducing to the engine. All the kW of gas introduced comes out as heat (bearings, water jacket, exhaust, etc.) and electrical power. If 10% efficient I can believe you are inputting 2kW of "gas" to get 200w of electrical power...
But let's have some numbers and play with the Engineering!
Thanks,
K2
In the first post there is a picture of the stepper motor that has all the information printed on it.
The engine is capable of higher rpms but first I must find a way to secure it to the work bench.
Ray
The engine is capable of higher rpms but first I must find a way to secure it to the work bench.
Ray
