Hi Kvom,
Yes it would, but then so would the plinth. What happened on the original was the timber base and plinth had the corner pieces and inserts affixed, and then it was painted to simulate a casting. I know I've not followed 100% to the original, but hopefully enough, and it's gone down well enough at home to be allowed space on the dining table, which I do like!
Thats a fair point on the finishing, i'll keep trying it at different levels of finish to see how it goes. To be 100% sure all the marks are gone it may be safer to take it right up to a shine, and then let it down a bit, if that makes sense. So many marks that are easily missed only spring to like at the final polish.
Many thanks!!