Yes, I understand your frustration, BUT...No nothing blows up.
There seems to be a general misunderstanding about this.
The 3D program has no idea if you have imported a sketch from AutoCad or elsewhere, or whether the sketch was created in Solidworks.
It is just lines, endpoints, lengths and angles, in the Solidworks database.
There is nothing in the SW database that says "this line was drawn in AutoCad".
A line is a line.
Any changes that need to be made to a sketch can be made directly to the sketch in Solidworks.
Sometimes I erase a sketch in Solidworks, and copy and paste an entirely new revised sketch in its place. No problems doing this.
There is no reference back to a 2D program; I keep hearing this over and over, and it is false.
You make the initial sketch in Autocad, copy and paste it into Solidworks, and extrude your shape.
You can do this for every sketch you add in the Solidworks model.
Any tweeking to the sketch can be done in Solidworks, or as I mentioned you can copy/paste over a previously copy/pasted sketch.
Solidworks does not know you are importing sketches instead of creating them in native Solidworks.
Solidworks does not act any differently if you import all your sketches or create all of your sketches in Solidworks.
With all due respect, clearly you have no concept of what is happening with the sketch import feature, or what is happening in Solidworks with or without imported sketches.
Jason keeps repeating the same false things too, so clearly he is not understanding the import process or how it works either.
I mean, it is one thing to not recommend something because you fully understand how it works, but to not recommend something, and then make a series of false statements, is not really a recommendation based on facts.
No slights are intended towards anyone, but I can see this conversation is getting nowhere, and there is no understanding of what I am doing with either AutoCad or Solidworks, or what the programs themselves are doing.
I am going to throw in the towel on this discussion; it appears hopeless.
.
The whole point of what myself (& many other users here) are saying, is that you DON'T need a "Secondary" CAD tool to achieve what you're doing. Like mentioned (many) times before, the sketching tools in the 3D CAD program are VERY good. I can't understand why you import sketches...maybe you can post a screen shot of the types of sketches you import?
Like Peter mentions, when I have tried to import a sketch (to save a little time, I'm lazy sometimes..), it will "Blow up", end points aren't closed, polylines are a problem, "UNCONSTRAINED geometry", unclosed sketches...
I spend more time trying to fix these issues than it takes me to recreate it in the 3D sketcher.
Your method DOES work, but why not use the tool that is already built into the program??
Don't "Throw in the towel", these posts have some very good points about how to use the software. Like you said, this works for you & it is important that users realize that this is an option to use. There may be some crazy reason why your option maybe the only one. I've seen stranger circumstances..
John
Last edited: