I don't think the scoring is significant. Because Quickdraw uses a steel sleeve, piston expansion is critical. That's the reason for the high silicon. Don't be afraid to run plenty of clearance, especially at the top of the piston. I bet Quickdraw would tell you what material they used. These days they try to run as many mass produced parts as possible. I'm impressed that you made your own pistons. I've done it and it's very time consuming on manual machines.
Are your rods slotted in the big end? The rod big end bearing is the weak point. We dynoed our engines to 25,000 rpm on an inertial dyno and ran to 23,000 rpm on our straight line record passes. the only rod failure I've had was on an M&D cast cylinder engine that I ran over 20,000 rpm for several race seasons. Fortunately, the rod and crankshaft were the only losses. Really good high rev Quickdraws had pretty flat power curves from 17,000 to 20,000 rpm. The peak came around 18.000 rpm. I don't know what your rngines power looks like, but they publish their brake dyno curves. Below is one on a couple of our engines in 2003.
Lohring Miller
View attachment 130723